Do You Actually Need a Rental Car in West Maui?
Guests ask us this more than any other planning question, usually a few weeks out, usually after seeing what a week of rental costs. The answer depends almost entirely on what you intend to do once you arrive. A couple settling into a Kahana condo for seven nights of beach and sunsets has a very different answer from a family planning Haleakala, Hana and a day on the water.
The Case for Not Renting One
Plenty of our guests fly in, take a shuttle, and never regret it.
West Maui is a strip. Kaanapali, Honokowai, Kahana, Napili and Kapalua sit along a single coastal road, and most condo complexes are within walking distance of a beach, a grocery run and somewhere to eat. If your week is built around the lanai and the sand in front of it, a car spends six days in a parking stall.
Rideshare covers the rest. Uber and Lyft both operate here, taxis are available, and Holoholo is a locally owned rideshare option. For a dinner reservation down the coast or a trip to a beach a few minutes away, that is cheaper than a week of rental plus any parking the property charges.
→ West Maui vacation rentals by area
Getting From Kahului Without a Car
Nearly every visitor lands at Kahului, on the other side of the island from the condos.
Two shuttle operators make that run regularly, Roberts Hawaii and Speedi Shuttle, and both will take you from the airport to your West Maui resort in an air-conditioned van. We recommend arranging the airport pickup in advance instead of sorting it out at the curb, particularly on an evening arrival when flights land in a cluster.
Maui Bus also runs fixed routes, and the county sets the general fare at $2 per boarding with a $4 daily pass. It is slow and it is not built around visitor schedules, but for a one-way trip down the coast it is the cheapest thing on the island.
When You Really Do Want the Car
Rent if the trip has a day in it that starts before sunrise or ends after dark somewhere remote.
Haleakala is the obvious one. So is the road to Hana: a full day of driving, and not something to hand to a rideshare driver. Upcountry farms, the north shore, Iao Valley, a surf lesson at a break that is not the one outside your building: all of these are car days. The guests happiest with their decision tend to rent for part of the week rather than all of it, picking the car up in Lahaina or Kaanapali for two or three days in the middle of the stay.
→ things to do around the island
Book It Early, Whatever You Decide
Maui has been running short on rental cars, and we tell every guest the same thing: reserve the vehicle when you reserve the condo.
Walking up to a counter at Kahului and expecting a car is how people end up paying twice the rate or driving something they did not want. The majors all have desks at the airport, and several of them, including Enterprise, Avis, Budget, National, Hertz and Alamo, also have locations out at Lahaina, Kaanapali or Kihei. That is what makes the mid-week pickup workable.
→ our car and shuttle information page
Parking Is the Part People Forget
The car is only half of the cost, and the other half is where it sleeps.
Parking arrangements differ by property, and the condo you book may hand you a permit, the front desk may issue one, or there may be a daily charge for it. A couple of our resorts tow vehicles that are not displaying a valid permit, so the first thing to do on arrival is work out where yours came from. This is worth settling before you book, not at check-in, and it is a reasonable question to put to us directly.
→ Kahana Sunset, beachfront condos on Keonenui Bay
What We'd Do With Seven Nights
If somebody asked us to decide for them, we would skip the car for the first two days, take a shuttle in, and let the family find its feet on the beach.
Then rent for three days in the middle for Haleakala, Hana and whatever else wants an early start, drop it, and finish the week on foot again. You pay for the days you use and you are not feeding a parking stall for a vehicle nobody is driving.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can you get around West Maui without a rental car?
A: Within West Maui, generally yes. The condo areas sit along one road, rideshare operates throughout, and shuttles run from the airport. Leaving West Maui for Haleakala, Hana or Upcountry is where a car becomes hard to replace.
Q: How far in advance should you book a rental car on Maui?
A: As early as you book the accommodation. The island has been short on vehicles, and the people who wait pay more or go without.
Q: Is there public transport on Maui?
A: Maui Bus runs fixed routes across the island at $2 per boarding. It works for simple point-to-point trips and does not work well for a day built around early starts or remote trailheads.
Q: Do West Maui condos charge for parking?
A: It varies by property. Some include a permit with the unit, some issue one at the front desk, and some charge a daily rate. Ask before you book so the number lands in your budget and not on your bill.
Ask Us Before You Book the Car
Parking is the detail that changes building to building, and it is the one we can look up in a minute. Name the condo you are considering and the shape of the week you have in mind, and the car question usually answers itself.
Sullivan Properties is at 10 Hoohui Rd. #110 in Lahaina, Hawaii, and every condo we manage is listed on mauiresorts.com.
Categories: